Skip to main content

The Fifth Petal by Brunonia Barry

The Fifth Petal is the third book by Brunonia Barry.  I read and reviewed her first book, The Lace Reader.  Her second novel was The Map of True Places, and I read that one, but apparently I did not review it for the blog.  All of Barry's novels are part of The Lace Reader series.  They all take place in Salem, Massachusetts, and the third one features characters from the first two novels as well as new characters.

The setting in Salem is important to the story, and it couldn't be set any place else.  The rich history of a city still scarred by the infamous witch hysteria of 1692-'93 plays a distinctive, heavy role in the story itself.  And the history of the witch trials and their victims is as fascinating as the story.

On Halloween a trio of teen boys harasses Rose, Salem's resident "banshee" and outcast woman, and when a god awful shrieking starts, the ring leader of the trio falls dead.  Thanks to his connections to an influential family in Salem, the modern day witch hunt demanding Rose's head for the suspicious death begins.  However, the family matriarch leading the charge has a subtle grudge against Rose that is rooted in the events surrounding the actions of a trio of beautiful young women who bewitched the town's men and were brutally murdered together nearly two decades ago.

One summer night twenty years earlier Rose, then a highly respected historian specializing in Salem witch trial history and genealogy, was found covered in the blood of the three slain women, who had also been her tenants.  That night the young women and Rose were attempting to consecrate the ground upon which their ancestors, five of Salem's accused witches, were hanged in 1692.  Only something went terribly wrong, leaving the three young women dead in the same ditch into which their ancestors' bodies had been discarded.  Rose, witness to the murders, was irrevocably psychologically traumatized, and Callie, the four year old daughter of one of the victims and also witness to the murders, was left motherless and traumatized.

The teenage boy's suspicious death dredges up the still unsolved murders of the young women and leads Chief Rafferty to re-open the case.  Meanwhile, Callie returns to town hoping to re-connect with Rose, whom she long thought dead, and to find out who killed her mother that night and why.  The parallels between the marginalization of Rose, who has lived rough and has been regularly harassed since the nights of the murders; the fear the town had of the three young women who had no qualms with wielding sexual power, and the hysteria of 1692 that targeted marginalized, outspoken women that society perceived as troublesome is an interesting study in the outcast, marginalized woman literary trope.

There are many interesting elements to this story, such as the Salem witch trial history and the way the genealogies of the murdered women connect to the mystery of the identity of their murderer.  Perhaps the most disturbing element is the way the town's growing hysteria towards Rose mirrors the hysteria that gripped the town in 1692.  The targets of both periods of collective hysteria were women living at the margins of society, women who possessed characteristics that invoked fear in the townsfolk.

--Reviewed by Ms. Angie


Popular posts from this blog

Broken by Karin Slaughter

Before I begin the formal review there are a few things I need to get off my chest in the wake of finishing this book; I'll do so without giving away too many (or any) spoilers.
The OUTRAGE!: the identity of Detective Lena Adams' new beau; the low depths to which Grant County's interim chief has sunk and brought the police force down with him; agent Will Trent's wife, Angie's, sixth sense/nasty habit of reappearing in his life just when he's slipping away from her. Thank God for small miracles though because while Angie was certainly referred to during the book, the broad didn't make an appearance. One sign that I've become way too invested in these characters is that I'd like to employ John Connolly's odd pair of assassins, Louis and Angel, to contract out a hit on Angie; do you think Karin Slaughter and John Connolly could work out a special cross over?
Hallelujah: Dr. Sara Linton and agent Will Trent are both back. There is no hallelujah for…

Crow Lake by Mary Lawson

When the end came, it seemed to do so completely out of the blue, and it wasn't until long afterward that I was able to see that there was a chain of events leading up to it. Some of those events had nothing to do with us, the Morrisons, but were solely the concern of the Pyes, who lived on a farm about a mile away and were our nearest neighbors." from page seven
I must confess that it took me longer than it really needed to in order to finish the novel Crow Lake by Mary Lawson. The entire story is building up to the big catastrophe that forever destroys all the hopes and dreams the Morrison clan ever dared to hope and dream for its future. In the eyes of the narrator, it is even worse than the tragedy of the car crash that claimed both parents' lives one evening on the heels of some good news the family has received and celebrated. Now you can see why I dreaded getting to the end of a book that drips in foreboding like nobody's business. What can be a worse tra…

In The Woods by Tana French

"What I warn you to remember is that I am a detective. Our relationship with the truth is fundamental, but cracked, refracting confusingly like fragmented glass. It is the core of our careers, the endgame of every move we make, and we pursue it with strategies painstakingly constructed of lies ... and every variation on deception. The truth is the most desirable woman in the world and we are the most jealous lovers, reflexively denying anyone else the slightest glimpse of her. We betray her routinely ... This is my job ... What I am telling you, before you begin my story, is this--two things: I crave truth. And I lie." opening lines of In The Woods chapter 1, pages 3-4
In The Woods by Tana French, an Irish writer, is an extremely well-written and well-crafted mystery novel. The downside is that this is French's debut novel, and her website (located at does not offer any insi…